MLBTSDB

Should you buy this?

To use

Worth the stubs for your squad

Good buy
  • 25% below the going rate — the typical 94 costs 7,800 stubs
  • Boosted by 2 captains

To flip

Buy low, sell higher, after tax

Not enough data

To hold

Hot in real life, may get upgraded

Not enough data

For exchanges

Cheapest way to feed an exchange

Not enough data

Where this card ranks

  • 149th best of 709 starting pitchers

Starting pitchers are ranked against starters, relievers against relievers, the way the team builder picks a staff.

Price history

Down 27% on a week ago.

What it costs to buyWhat you'd get selling
010,00020,00030,00040,00050,000Oct 10Oct 16Oct 23Oct 2912,4989,000
Price history

Ratings

Stamina
93
K/9
60
H/9
93
BB/9
91
Velocity
99
Control
91
Break
95

Your ratings

How this card ranks under ratings built for specific jobs. Make one that weighs what you care about, and every card page shows where that card lands.

Build your own rating

Pitching

Stamina
93
Pitching clutch
90
H/9
93
K/9
60
BB/9
91
Top 9%
HR/9
90
Top 9%
Velocity
99
Top 1%
Control
91
Top 9%
Break
95
Stuff
90

Pitches

4-Seam Fastball
96 mph
Sinker
95 mph
Cutter
89 mph
Slurve
82 mph
Circle Change
88 mph

Player

Position
SP
Bats
L
Throws
L
Age
23
Height
6'6"
Weight
250 lbs
Born
Oklahoma
Number
70

Fielding & running

Fielding
58
Arm strength
60
Arm accuracy
64
Blocking
0
Speed
29
Baserunning
0
Steal
6
Reaction vs L
64
Reaction vs R
64

Real-world tendencies

Arm slot
Low three-quarter 28°

A common release point among MLB pitchers (2026 Statcast)

SubmarineSidearmLow three-quarterThree-quarterHigh three-quarterOver the top

Faint lines: all 274 pitchers in this edition who throw with the same hand.

Quirks

Obtained from

Captains that boost this card

Build around one of these and this card gets their ability boost.

More Red Sox at SP

Other versions of this player

Questions

How do you get Payton Tolle?
Buy it on the Community Market, where it costs about 14,489 stubs right now.
How much is Payton Tolle worth?
It usually sells for about 7,570 stubs.
What does Payton Tolle quicksell for?
The game will always buy it back for 4,750 stubs.
What quirks does Payton Tolle have?
Homebody, Night Player, and Break Outlier.

Similar cards

Same position, comparable ratings

98% more

47% cheaper

70% cheaper

10% cheaper

34% cheaper

46% cheaper

Keep browsing