Best by pitch
The best card for every pitch in the game.
- 4-Seam FastballBest: Captain Eric Gagne
- SliderBest: Finest Robb Nen
- SinkerBest: Milestone Ubaldo Jimenez
- Circle ChangeBest: 2025 Finest Tarik Skubal
- CutterBest: Awards Emmanuel Clase
- CurveballBest: 2025 Finest Sonny Gray
- SweeperBest: 2025 Finest Sonny Gray
- ChangeupBest: The Negro Leagues Leroy Matlock
- 12-6 CurveBest: Hall of Fame Cy Young
- 2-Seam FastballBest: Captain Hal Newhouser
- SplitterBest: 2025 Postseason Yoshinobu Yamamoto
- SlurveBest: Topps Now Trevor McDonald
- Knuckle-curveBest: Cornerstone Craig Kimbrel
- ScrewballBest: The Negro Leagues Rube Foster
- Sweeping CurveBest: Captain Hal Newhouser
