Best by pitch
The best card for every pitch in the game.
- 4-Seam FastballBest: Finest Troy Percival
- SliderBest: 2023 Finest Emmanuel Clase
- Circle ChangeBest: 2023 Finest Tarik Skubal
- SinkerBest: Snapshot Walter Johnson
- CurveballBest: Finest Lefty Grove
- 2-Seam FastballBest: Topps Now Josh Hader
- CutterBest: 2023 Finest Emmanuel Clase
- ChangeupBest: 2023 Finest Logan Webb
- 12-6 CurveBest: Topps Now Domingo German
- SlurveBest: Incognito Big Red
- SplitterBest: Prime Bruce Sutter
- Knuckle-curveBest: 2023 Finest Zac Gallen
- Sweeping CurveBest: World Baseball Classic Adam Wainwright
- ScrewballBest: World Baseball Classic Devin Williams
- ForkballBest: Finest Tom Henke
