Best by pitch
The best card for every pitch in the game.
- 4-Seam FastballBest: Milestone Pedro Martinez
- SliderBest: Finest Jake Arrieta
- SinkerBest: Spotlight Brandyn Garcia
- Circle ChangeBest: World Baseball Classic Ondrej Satoria
- CutterBest: Prime Jonathan Broxton
- SweeperBest: Spotlight Brandyn Garcia
- CurveballBest: Field of Dreams Roy Halladay
- ChangeupBest: Field of Dreams Whitey Ford
- SplitterBest: New Threads Casey Mize
- 12-6 CurveBest: 2026 All-Star Nick Martinez
- 2-Seam FastballBest: 2026 Draft Liam Peterson
- SlurveBest: Spotlight Connor Prielipp
- Knuckle-curveBest: Spotlight Cade Cavalli
