MLBTSDB

Yankees all-time team

The best Yankees team you can build in MLB 26 would cost about 1,023,273 stubs at today's prices.

13 of its cards aren't on the market right now, so they aren't in that total.

Its best player is Phil Rizzuto, a 99 overall.

Built from 120 cards, the same way the team builder picks a squad.

Open this team in the team builderSee the real Yankees roster

Lineup against right-handed pitching

  1. 1. SS
    Phil RizzutoAwards · SS
    99
  2. 2. DH
    Babe RuthFinest · LF
    99
  3. 3. C
    Jorge PosadaSubway · C
    99
  4. 4. 3B
    Graig NettlesAwards · 3B
    99
  5. 5. LF
    Curtis GrandersonMoonshot · CF
    99
  6. 6. CF
    Bernie WilliamsMilestone · CF
    99
  7. 7. 2B
    Mickey MantleMoonshot · CF
    99
  8. 8. RF
    Chili DavisMilestone · CF
    99
  9. 9. 1B
    Johnny DamonMoonshot · CF
    99

Bench

  1. Starts vs LHP
    Alfonso SorianoSignature · 2B
    99
  2. Starts vs LHP
    Derek JeterSubway · SS
    99
  3. Starts vs LHP
    George Lombard Jr.Pipeline · SS
    99
  4. Pinch-hitter
    Ben Rice2026 Postseason · 1B
    99

Starting rotation

  1. SP1
    Mike MussinaSubway · SP
    99
  2. SP2
    Ryan WeathersSpotlight · SP
    99
  3. SP3
    Whitey FordField of Dreams · SP
    98
  4. SP4
    Carlos LagrangePipeline · SP
    98
  5. SP5
    CC SabathiaMilestone · SP
    99

Bullpen

  1. vs righties
    Andrew MillerVeteran · CP
    90
  2. Middle relief
    Cam Schlittler2026 All-Star · SP
    98
  3. vs lefties
    Hunter Dietz2026 Draft · SP
    96
  4. Middle relief
    Harrison CohenWorld Baseball Classic · RP
    85
  5. Long relief
    Andy PettitteStandout · SP
    94
  6. vs lefties
    Carlos RodónSummer · SP
    94
  7. Setup
    Brent HeadrickSpotlight · RP
    98
  8. Closer
    Paul BlackburnSpotlight · RP
    99