Best defensive catchers

Ranked on: Fielding 34% · Reaction 26% · Arm accuracy 22% · Arm strength 18%. Ranked among cards rated 90 overall and above — below that the order is simply the overall rating again.

1. 1Biz MackeyThe Negro Leagues · Arm accuracy 99% · Reaction 99%99125,000top 2%
2. 2Dillon Dingler2025 Finest · Fielding 98% · Arm strength 98%99137,000top 4%
3. 3Patrick BaileySpotlight · Arm accuracy 99% · Reaction 99%9947,000top 6%
4. 4Johnny BenchCornerstone · Arm accuracy 99% · Fielding 96%99top 8%
5. 5Cal Raleigh2025 Finest · Fielding 96% · Reaction 94%99top 10%
6. 6Gary SanchezSpotlight · Arm strength 98% · Arm accuracy 97%99top 12%
7. 7Alejandro Kirk2025 Postseason · Fielding 98% · Reaction 97%99top 14%
8. 8Francisco AlvarezSpotlight · Arm accuracy 96% · Reaction 95%9944,000top 16%
9. 9Gabriel MorenoSpotlight · Arm accuracy 97% · Fielding 95%99top 18%
10. 10Freddy FerminNew Threads · Arm accuracy 99% · Fielding 89%97top 20%
11. 11Gary CarterFinest · Arm strength 90% · Arm accuracy 89%99top 22%
12. 12Adley RutschmanNeon · Reaction 94% · Arm strength 90%99top 24%
13. 13William Contreras2025 Finest · Arm strength 90% · Reaction 90%99top 25%
14. 14Carson Kelly2025 Postseason · Arm accuracy 99% · Reaction 92%99top 27%
15. 15Will Smith2025 Postseason · Arm accuracy 97% · Reaction 96%99top 29%
16. 16Kyle TeelNeon · Arm accuracy 91% · Arm strength 85%99top 31%
17. 17Luke Stevenson2025 Draft · Arm strength 91% · Arm accuracy 89%9615,000top 33%
18. 18Carlos NarváezTopps Now · Fielding 95% · Arm accuracy 91%93285,000top 35%
19. 19Jonah HeimAwards · Reaction 88% · Fielding 87%9013,000top 37%
20. 20Caden Bodine2025 Draft · Arm accuracy 94% · Reaction 88%96top 39%
21. 21Jimmy CrooksTopps Now · Arm strength 87% · Arm accuracy 85%97top 41%
22. 22Josh GibsonHall of Fame · Arm accuracy 91% · Arm strength 84%9982,999top 43%
23. 23Jason VaritekFinest · Arm accuracy 88% · Arm strength 85%99539,999top 45%
24. 24Carlos Santanaalso 1BMilestone · Reaction 87% · Fielding 86%99top 47%
25. 25Craig Biggioalso 2BCornerstone · Reaction 87% · Fielding 86%99top 49%
26. 26Ivan RodriguezMoonshot · Arm accuracy 99% · Arm strength 98%9949,000top 50%
27. 27Drake Baldwin2025 Finest · Reaction 95% · Fielding 83%99top 52%
28. 28Ted SimmonsHall of Fame · Reaction 83% · Arm strength 78%9932,000top 54%
29. 29Carter JensenSpotlight · Arm strength 87% · Reaction 78%9941,000top 56%
30. 30J.T. RealmutoMilestone · Arm strength 92% · Reaction 92%99top 58%
31. 31Joe MauerMoonshot · Arm strength 95% · Arm accuracy 91%99top 60%
32. 32Shea LangeliersSpotlight · Arm strength 95% · Arm accuracy 83%99top 62%
33. 33Salvador PerezPrime · Arm accuracy 75% · Fielding 73%94top 64%
34. 34Danny JansenTopps Now · Fielding 87% · Arm accuracy 75%98top 66%
35. 35Samuel BasalloTopps Now · Arm strength 90% · Arm accuracy 88%97top 68%
36. 36Harry FordTopps Now · Arm strength 78% · Arm accuracy 71%97top 70%
37. 37Logan O'HoppeNeon · Reaction 94% · Arm strength 72%99top 72%
38. 38Hunter Goodman2025 Finest · Arm strength 82% · Reaction 81%99110,000top 74%
39. 39Jorge PosadaSignature · Arm strength 72% · Fielding 70%99top 75%
40. 40Bo NaylorColor Storm · Fielding 81% · Reaction 76%92top 77%
41. 41Mike PiazzaHall of Fame · Arm strength 69% · Fielding 65%9963,997top 79%
42. 42Willson Contrerasalso 1BSpotlight · Arm strength 88% · Arm accuracy 68%9128,811top 81%
43. 43Tyler Soderstromalso LFNeon · Arm strength 91% · Arm accuracy 71%99top 83%
44. 44Iván HerreraSpotlight · Reaction 93% · Fielding 63%9930,000top 85%
45. 45Mike NapoliPrime · Arm accuracy 71% · Arm strength 65%99130,000top 87%
46. 46Dalton RushingTopps Now · Arm strength 65% · Arm accuracy 61%9063,207top 89%
47. 47Braxton FulfordTopps Now · Reaction 67% · Arm accuracy 61%9244,990top 91%
48. 48Ike Irishalso RF2025 Draft · Arm accuracy 87% · Arm strength 82%97top 93%
49. 49Ben Ricealso 1B2025 Finest · Fielding 65% · Arm accuracy 58%99top 95%
50. 50Yasmani GrandalMoonshot · Fielding 81% · Arm strength 65%91top 97%
51. 51Keibert RuizColor Storm · Reaction 70% · Arm accuracy 28%91top 99%
52. 52Kyle SchwarberPipeline Past · Arm strength 35% · Fielding 26%9261,000top 100%