MLBTSDB

Cardinals all-time team

The best Cardinals team you can build in MLB 25 would cost about 1,566,759 stubs at today's prices.

11 of its cards aren't on the market right now, so they aren't in that total.

Its best player is Terry Pendleton, a 99 overall.

Built from 87 cards, the same way the team builder picks a squad.

Open this team in the team builderSee the real Cardinals roster

Lineup against right-handed pitching

  1. 1. 3B
    Terry PendletonCaptain · 3B
    99
  2. 2. 1B
    Stan MusialSpooky · RF
    99
  3. 3. SS
    Ozzie SmithMoonshot · SS
    99
  4. 4. RF
    Rick AnkielHome Run Derby X · CF
    99
  5. 5. LF
    Tyler O'NeillAwards · LF
    99
  6. 6. DH
    Joe TorreMilestone · 3B
    99
  7. 7. 2B
    JJ WetherholtNeon · SS
    99
  8. 8. C
    Ted SimmonsHall of Fame · C
    99
  9. 9. CF
    Lou BrockHall of Fame · LF
    99

Bench

  1. Starts vs LHP
    Iván HerreraSpotlight · C
    99
  2. Pinch-hitter
    Brendan Donovan2025 All-Star · 2B
    96
  3. Speedster
    Victor Scott IILive · CF
    78
  4. Defense
    Masyn WinnLive · SS
    83

Starting rotation

  1. SP1
    Bob GibsonAwards · SP
    99
  2. SP2
    Matthew LiberatoreSpotlight · SP
    90
  3. SP3
    Erick FeddeTopps Now · SP
    88
  4. SP4
    Liam Doyle2025 Draft · SP
    98
  5. SP5
    Sonny Gray2025 Finest · SP
    99

Bullpen

  1. Long relief
    Quinn MathewsPipeline · SP
    83
  2. Middle relief
    Ryan HelsleyBreakout · CP
    94
  3. Middle relief
    Riley O'BrienLive · RP
    72
  4. Middle relief
    Bruce SutterVeteran · CP
    80
  5. Middle relief
    Lee SmithStandout · CP
    95
  6. Middle relief
    Kyle LeahyLive · RP
    69
  7. Setup
    JoJo RomeroSpotlight · RP
    96
  8. Closer
    Matt SvansonSpotlight · RP
    99