Should you buy this?
Worth the stubs for your squad
Buy low, sell higher, after tax
Hot in real life, may get upgraded
Cheapest way to feed an exchange
Where this card ranks
- 744th best of 813 third basemen
- 668th best of 740 first basemen
- 1,014th best of 1,114 left fielders
- 942nd best of 1,033 right fielders
- 1,708th best of 1,976 designated hitters
Ranked the way the team builder judges a lineup spot: hitting against both hands, speed, and defense at that position.
Price history
Holding steady, with no big price moves lately.
Price history
Ratings
Your ratings
How this card ranks under ratings built for specific jobs. Make one that weighs what you care about, and every card page shows where that card lands.
- Righty CrusherStaff pick#1474 of 1,976 hitters51.0
- Cleanup MasherStaff pick#1590 of 1,976 hitters45.8
- Platoon-Proof BatStaff pick#1626 of 1,976 hitters41.5
Hitting
- Contact vs L
- 41
- Contact vs R
- 52
- Power vs L
- 42
- Power vs R
- 52
- Plate vision
- 28
- Plate discipline
- 54
- Batting clutch
- 44
- Bunting
- 28
- Drag bunting
- 39
- Durability
- 75
Player
- Team
- Free Agents
- Position
- 3B
- Secondary
- 1B, LF, RF
- Bats
- L
- Throws
- R
- Age
- 29
- Height
- 6'2"
- Weight
- 205 lbs
- Born
- Massachusetts
- Number
- 73
Fielding & running
- Fielding
- 60
- Arm strength
- 62
- Arm accuracy
- 53
- Blocking
- 0
- Speed
- 65
- Baserunning
- 11
- Reaction
- 52
Captains that boost this card
Build around one of these and this card gets their ability boost.
More Free Agents at 3B
Questions
- How do you get Will Toffey?
- Buy it on the Community Market, where it costs about 9 stubs right now.
- How much is Will Toffey worth?
- It costs about 9 stubs to buy right now.
- Where can I see Will Toffey's real-life stats?
- On his player page: his career stats, awards, and every card of him in every edition.
Similar cards
Same position, comparable ratings
444% more
22% more
10633% more
33% more
978% more
456% more

















