Best defensive first basemen
Catches what he can reach and throws out what he cannot.
198 cards ranked
Ranked on: Fielding 34% · Reaction 26% · Arm accuracy 22% · Arm strength 18%. Ranked among cards rated 90 overall and above — below that the order is simply the overall rating again.
- 1
Cody Bellingeralso RFLAD · Finest · Reaction 99% · Fielding 99%99 - 2
Mike Schmidtalso 3BPHI · Hyper · Arm accuracy 97% · Fielding 97%99 - 3
Joey Galloalso 3BTEX · Finest · Arm accuracy 99% · Arm strength 97%99 - 4
Al Kalinealso RFDET · Action Figure · Fielding 96% · Arm accuracy 94%9924,500 - 5
Ryan McMahonalso 3BCOL · 2024 Finest · Fielding 99% · Reaction 96%99172,554 - 6
Patrick Baileyalso CSF · Topps Now · Reaction 99% · Fielding 99%939,999 - 7
Mickey Mantlealso CFNYY · Hall of Fame · Arm accuracy 95% · Arm strength 94%99 - 8
Jackson Merrillalso CFSD · 2024 Finest · Arm strength 96% · Reaction 93%99 - 9
Gunnar Hendersonalso SSBAL · Topps Now · Arm strength 98% · Arm accuracy 94%99 - 10
Ernie Banksalso SSCHC · Action Figure · Reaction 93% · Fielding 93%99 - 11
Joe Maueralso CMIN · Hall of Fame · Fielding 95% · Reaction 94%99 - 12
Nolan Arenadoalso 3BSTL · Captain · Fielding 99% · Reaction 98%99 - 13
Buck O'NeilFA · Jin Kim · Reaction 99% · Fielding 99%9915,000 - 14
Kevin Youkilisalso 3BBOS · Signature · Arm accuracy 97% · Reaction 94%9916,000 - 15
Hank Aaronalso RFATL · Hall of Fame · Arm accuracy 91% · Arm strength 91%99 - 16
Buck LeonardFA · Jin Kim · Arm accuracy 94% · Fielding 94%9928,888 - 17
Rap Dixonalso RFFA · Jin Kim · Reaction 92% · Fielding 90%9910,320 - 18
Jim Edmondsalso CFLAA · Hyper · Fielding 95% · Reaction 90%99 - 19
Mike Yastrzemskialso RFSF · Finest · Fielding 95% · Reaction 94%99 - 20
Johnny Benchalso CCIN · Action Figure · Arm strength 93% · Fielding 93%99 - 21
Logan O'Hoppealso CLAA · The Show Classics · Arm strength 91% · Fielding 90%9935,000 - 22
Jackie Robinsonalso 2BLAD · Hall of Fame · Reaction 94% · Fielding 89%99 - 23
Gary Carteralso CNYM · Hyper · Arm strength 92% · Fielding 89%99 - 24
Taylor Wardalso LFLAA · 2024 Finest · Reaction 96% · Arm accuracy 87%99 - 25
Willie Maysalso 3BSF · Out of Position · Reaction 90% · Fielding 89%95 - 26
J.T. Realmutoalso CMIA · Captain · Arm strength 93% · Arm accuracy 89%99 - 27
Honus Wagneralso SSPIT · Milestone · Fielding 89% · Reaction 86%99177,777 - 28
Yasmani Grandalalso CCWS · Topps Now · Reaction 99% · Fielding 90%97 - 29
Javier Báezalso SSDET · Spooky · Arm strength 95% · Fielding 94%99 - 30
Rich Auriliaalso SSSF · Action Figure · Fielding 89% · Reaction 86%99 - 31
Austin Wellsalso CNYY · 2024 Postseason · Fielding 93% · Reaction 89%99 - 32
Whit Merrifieldalso 2BKC · Hyper · Reaction 90% · Fielding 89%99 - 33
D.J. LeMahieualso 2BNYY · Hyper · Arm accuracy 94% · Fielding 90%99 - 34
Joc Pedersonalso LFLAD · Captain · Reaction 96% · Fielding 89%99 - 35
Justin Turneralso 3BLAD · Action Figure · Reaction 93% · Arm accuracy 87%99 - 36
Kole Calhounalso RFLAA · Captain · Arm strength 94% · Arm accuracy 84%99 - 37
Andy Ibáñezalso 3BDET · 2024 Postseason · Fielding 97% · Arm accuracy 94%99 - 38
Don MattinglyNYY · Captain · Reaction 93% · Fielding 91%99 - 39
Eddie Mathewsalso 3BATL · Action Figure · Arm strength 84% · Reaction 84%99277,799 - 40
Josh Gibsonalso CFA · Jin Kim · Arm accuracy 91% · Fielding 81%9957,000 - 41
Ken Griffey Sr.also RFCIN · Captain · Reaction 84% · Fielding 83%99 - 42
Trey Lipscombalso 3BWAS · Topps Now · Arm accuracy 87% · Arm strength 87%976,850 - 43
Cam Collieralso 3BCIN · Futures Skills Showcase · Arm strength 91% · Arm accuracy 86%93 - 44
Larry Walkeralso RFWAS · All-Star Game · Arm accuracy 91% · Arm strength 86%92 - 45
Manny Machadoalso 3BSD · Incognito · Fielding 95% · Arm strength 78%9315,000 - 46
Zach DezenzoHOU · Topps Now · Reaction 89% · Fielding 85%98 - 47
Bryce HarperPHI · 2024 Finest · Arm accuracy 84% · Reaction 84%99 - 48
Austin Rileyalso 3BATL · Spooky · Arm accuracy 91% · Fielding 83%99 - 49
Kris Bryantalso 3BCHC · Awards · Fielding 85% · Reaction 84%9939,936 - 50
Tyler Fitzgeraldalso SSSF · Season Awards · Fielding 85% · Arm accuracy 82%99 - 51
Salvador Perezalso CKC · Awards · Arm accuracy 97% · Arm strength 87%99304,555 - 52
Niko Goodrumalso SSDET · The Show Classics · Reaction 99% · Fielding 96%977,200 - 53
Monte Irvinalso LFSF · Prime · Arm strength 87% · Arm accuracy 79%976,555 - 54
Alex Bregmanalso 3BHOU · 2024 Finest · Fielding 93% · Reaction 86%99 - 55
Jonathan ArandaTB · Season Awards · Fielding 85% · Reaction 80%98 - 56
Brandon BeltSF · Captain · Arm accuracy 91% · Reaction 89%99 - 57
Addison Bargeralso 3BTOR · Topps Now · Arm strength 98% · Arm accuracy 94%93 - 58
Paul GoldschmidtARI · Finest · Fielding 97% · Arm accuracy 91%99 - 59
Brandon Lowealso 2BTB · Captain · Arm accuracy 91% · Reaction 90%99 - 60
George Brettalso 3BKC · Milestone · Fielding 85% · Arm accuracy 79%99 - 61
Jhonkensy Noelalso RFCLE · 2024 Postseason · Arm accuracy 99% · Arm strength 87%99 - 62
Nick KurtzOAK · 2024 Draft · Reaction 84% · Fielding 83%9724,950 - 63
Stan Musialalso LFSTL · Hall of Fame · Fielding 83% · Arm strength 76%99 - 64
Bryan Ramosalso 3BCWS · Topps Now · Reaction 77% · Fielding 77%967,500 - 65
Kerry Carpenteralso RFDET · 2024 Postseason · Arm strength 92% · Arm accuracy 86%99 - 66
Will Wagneralso 2BTOR · Topps Now · Fielding 79% · Reaction 77%98 - 67
Matt OlsonOAK · Awards · Fielding 96% · Reaction 84%9955,336 - 68
Wade Boggsalso 3BBOS · Hyper · Fielding 79% · Arm accuracy 77%99 - 69
David FryCLE · 2024 Postseason · Arm strength 84% · Reaction 81%99 - 70
Logan Driscollalso CTB · Topps Now · Reaction 84% · Arm strength 81%96 - 71
Samuel Basalloalso CBAL · Pipeline · Arm accuracy 94% · Arm strength 89%9916,667 - 72
Todd HeltonCOL · Hall of Fame · Fielding 85% · Reaction 75%99 - 73
Mark Vientosalso 3BNYM · 2024 Postseason · Arm strength 93% · Arm accuracy 87%99 - 74
Freddie FreemanLAD · 2024 Postseason · Arm accuracy 99% · Fielding 79%99 - 75
Luis ArraezSD · Milestone · Arm accuracy 96% · Reaction 80%99 - 76
Moises Ballesterosalso CCHC · Futures Skills Showcase · Arm accuracy 77% · Reaction 77%93 - 77
Thomas Saggesealso 2BSTL · Topps Now · Reaction 86% · Fielding 79%97 - 78
Matt Carpenteralso 2BSTL · Awards · Arm accuracy 87% · Fielding 83%99 - 79
Nolan Ryanalso CFHOU · Out of Position · Arm strength 98% · Reaction 97%95 - 80
Oswaldo Cabreraalso 3BNYY · Season Awards · Reaction 96% · Arm strength 84%929,999 - 81
Christian WalkerARI · Season Awards · Fielding 96% · Reaction 84%959,000 - 82
Coby Mayoalso 3BBAL · Pipeline · Arm strength 96% · Arm accuracy 89%947,000 - 83
Matt Vierlingalso CFDET · Topps Now · Arm strength 81% · Reaction 75%978,999 - 84
James McCannalso CBAL · Topps Now · Arm strength 82% · Reaction 75%919,789 - 85
Jurickson Profaralso LFSD · Season Awards · Arm strength 86% · Arm accuracy 72%99 - 86
John KrukPHI · Action Figure · Reaction 84% · Fielding 73%99 - 87
Billy Williamsalso LFCHC · Action Figure · Arm strength 81% · Fielding 73%9919,000 - 88
Joey VottoCIN · Action Figure · Fielding 94% · Reaction 77%9935,536 - 89
Rod Carewalso 2BMIN · Action Figure · Reaction 81% · Fielding 73%99 - 90
Raul Ibanezalso LFSEA · Action Figure · Arm accuracy 79% · Arm strength 78%99 - 91
Mike NapoliBOS · Finest · Reaction 86% · Arm accuracy 75%99 - 92
Willie Stargellalso LFPIT · Hyper · Arm strength 84% · Arm accuracy 82%99 - 93
Ryan HowardPHI · Spooky · Reaction 80% · Fielding 79%99 - 94
Tre' MorganTB · Futures Skills Showcase · Reaction 75% · Fielding 73%93 - 95
PJ Morlandoalso RFMIA · 2024 Draft · Arm accuracy 82% · Reaction 72%95 - 96
Paul Skenesalso CPIT · Out of Position · Arm strength 98% · Arm accuracy 72%95 - 97
Yainer Diazalso CHOU · Mexico City Series · Arm strength 98% · Arm accuracy 82%9613,333 - 98
Matt Hollidayalso LFCOL · Action Figure · Reaction 75% · Arm strength 74%99 - 99
Caleb Lomavitaalso CWAS · 2024 Draft · Arm strength 81% · Arm accuracy 79%95 - 100
Spencer HorwitzTOR · Topps Now · Reaction 89% · Fielding 73%9715,000