# Best defensive first basemen

> The best defensive first basemen in MLB 25, ranked against every card eligible there, with live Community Market prices.

Canonical: https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/best/glove/1b

Catches what he can reach and throws out what he cannot.

147 cards ranked

**Ranked on:** Fielding 34% · Reaction 26% · Arm accuracy 22% · Arm strength 18%. Ranked among cards rated 90 overall and above — below that the order is simply the overall rating again.

| # | Card | OVR | Why | Buy now |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 1 | [Biz Mackey](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/the-negro-leagues-biz-mackey-9bfa48c6) (also C) | 99 | FA · The Negro Leagues · Arm accuracy 99% · Reaction 99% | 125,000 |
| 2 | [Judy Johnson](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/the-negro-leagues-judy-johnson-f97cf2c7) (also 3B) | 99 | FA · The Negro Leagues · Reaction 99% · Fielding 98% | 20,000 |
| 3 | [Johnny Bench](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/cornerstone-johnny-bench-6a19b3ea) (also C) | 99 | CIN · Cornerstone · Arm accuracy 99% · Fielding 96% |  |
| 4 | [Turkey Stearnes](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/the-negro-leagues-turkey-stearnes-9d305702) (also CF) | 99 | FA · The Negro Leagues · Fielding 98% · Arm accuracy 95% |  |
| 5 | [Alex Gordon](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/cornerstone-alex-gordon-2c49a77c) (also LF) | 95 | KC · Cornerstone · Reaction 99% · Arm accuracy 97% |  |
| 6 | [Cody Bellinger](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/2025-finest-cody-bellinger-1f1acf13) (also LF) | 99 | NYY · 2025 Finest · Arm accuracy 95% · Fielding 93% |  |
| 7 | [Jim Edmonds](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/awards-jim-edmonds-27f2b7bf) (also CF) | 99 | LAA · Awards · Reaction 97% · Fielding 93% |  |
| 8 | [Chase Utley](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/awards-chase-utley-f3fd691d) (also 2B) | 99 | PHI · Awards · Reaction 99% · Fielding 98% | 22,000 |
| 9 | [Eddie Murray](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/hall-of-fame-eddie-murray-add08f92) | 99 | BAL · Hall of Fame · Reaction 94% · Fielding 93% | 340,999 |
| 10 | [Chase Headley](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/finest-chase-headley-0e362248) (also 3B) | 99 | SD · Finest · Reaction 96% · Fielding 93% | 28,999 |
| 11 | [Buck O'Neil](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/the-negro-leagues-buck-o-neil-ffe51feb) | 99 | FA · The Negro Leagues · Reaction 99% · Fielding 98% |  |
| 12 | [Jared Triolo](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/spotlight-jared-triolo-27666dd2) (also SS) | 98 | PIT · Spotlight · Arm accuracy 98% · Fielding 95% |  |
| 13 | [Buck Leonard](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/the-negro-leagues-buck-leonard-bae12df2) | 99 | FA · The Negro Leagues · Arm accuracy 94% · Fielding 93% |  |
| 14 | [DJ LeMahieu](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/signature-dj-lemahieu-6f60ee91) (also 2B) | 98 | COL · Signature · Reaction 99% · Fielding 98% |  |
| 15 | [Honus Wagner](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/hall-of-fame-honus-wagner-a521ab49) (also SS) | 99 | PIT · Hall of Fame · Reaction 92% · Fielding 92% | 798,999 |
| 16 | [Oscar Charleston](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/ranked-1000-oscar-charleston-f9b28d7a) (also CF) | 99 | FA · Ranked 1000 · Fielding 93% · Reaction 92% |  |
| 17 | [Gary Carter](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/finest-gary-carter-5604c82c) (also C) | 99 | NYM · Finest · Arm strength 90% · Arm accuracy 89% |  |
| 18 | [Jurickson Profar](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/topps-now-jurickson-profar-4fee7d7b) (also LF) | 97 | ATL · Topps Now · Reaction 99% · Fielding 98% |  |
| 19 | [Enrique Hernández](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/2025-postseason-enrique-hernandez-6557f189) (also LF) | 99 | LAD · 2025 Postseason · Reaction 92% · Fielding 92% |  |
| 20 | [D.J. LeMahieu](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/awards-d-j-lemahieu-f832c124) (also 3B) | 92 | NYY · Awards · Reaction 96% · Fielding 95% | 25,000 |
| 21 | [Monte Irvin](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/the-negro-leagues-monte-irvin-8585e3ef) (also LF) | 99 | FA · The Negro Leagues · Arm strength 94% · Fielding 86% |  |
| 22 | [Carlos Narváez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/topps-now-carlos-narvaez-12c2175c) (also C) | 93 | BOS · Topps Now · Fielding 95% · Arm accuracy 91% | 285,000 |
| 23 | [Jeimer Candelario](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/the-show-classics-jeimer-candelario-c3a08823) (also 3B) | 99 | DET · The Show Classics · Arm accuracy 91% · Reaction 88% | 250,000 |
| 24 | [Adrian Gonzalez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/home-run-derby-x-adrian-gonzalez-c1fe85b8) | 99 | LAD · Home Run Derby X · Fielding 93% · Reaction 87% | 198,000 |
| 25 | [Ryan Zimmerman](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/home-run-derby-x-ryan-zimmerman-05d5391c) (also 3B) | 99 | WAS · Home Run Derby X · Fielding 96% · Reaction 94% | 180,000 |
| 26 | [Ben Zobrist](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/home-run-derby-x-ben-zobrist-db9df5ec) (also 2B) | 99 | CHC · Home Run Derby X · Fielding 86% · Reaction 85% |  |
| 27 | [Paul Goldschmidt](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/finest-paul-goldschmidt-804ebedd) | 99 | ARI · Finest · Arm accuracy 99% · Reaction 92% |  |
| 28 | [Josh Gibson](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/hall-of-fame-josh-gibson-c10bfcaf) (also C) | 99 | FA · Hall of Fame · Arm accuracy 91% · Arm strength 84% | 82,999 |
| 29 | [Nick Swisher](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/home-run-derby-x-nick-swisher-0c754e0f) (also RF) | 99 | NYY · Home Run Derby X · Reaction 88% · Arm accuracy 83% | 227,666 |
| 30 | [Todd Helton](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/prime-todd-helton-311360f4) | 99 | COL · Prime · Fielding 93% · Reaction 92% |  |
| 31 | [Dean Curley](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/2025-draft-dean-curley-fba5d674) (also SS) | 95 | CLE · 2025 Draft · Arm strength 95% · Reaction 81% |  |
| 32 | [George Brett](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/hall-of-fame-george-brett-9485940b) (also 3B) | 99 | KC · Hall of Fame · Arm accuracy 85% · Fielding 85% | 65,000 |
| 33 | [Carlos Santana](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/milestone-carlos-santana-efb98336) | 99 | CLE · Milestone · Reaction 87% · Fielding 86% |  |
| 34 | [Wade Boggs](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/cornerstone-wade-boggs-4579da10) (also 3B) | 99 | BOS · Cornerstone · Fielding 87% · Reaction 83% |  |
| 35 | [Stan Musial](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/spooky-stan-musial-cfdb955d) (also RF) | 99 | STL · Spooky · Fielding 83% · Arm strength 82% |  |
| 36 | [Spencer Steer](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/spotlight-spencer-steer-a44b1fed) | 99 | CIN · Spotlight · Reaction 92% · Fielding 92% |  |
| 37 | [Emmanuel Rivera](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/topps-now-emmanuel-rivera-c152935f) (also 3B) | 97 | BAL · Topps Now · Fielding 89% · Reaction 85% | 23,000 |
| 38 | [Michael Helman](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/spotlight-michael-helman-36a422cc) (also CF) | 99 | TEX · Spotlight · Fielding 87% · Arm strength 87% | 21,222 |
| 39 | [Joc Pederson](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/finest-joc-pederson-52f625b6) (also LF) | 99 | LAD · Finest · Arm accuracy 93% · Arm strength 82% |  |
| 40 | [Jhonkensy Noel](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/the-show-classics-jhonkensy-noel-322cbca1) (also RF) | 99 | CLE · The Show Classics · Arm accuracy 99% · Arm strength 90% | 134,999 |
| 41 | [Eddie Mathews](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/cornerstone-eddie-mathews-0a68dd43) (also 3B) | 99 | ATL · Cornerstone · Arm strength 84% · Arm accuracy 80% |  |
| 42 | [Kyle Stowers](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/2025-finest-kyle-stowers-70fcbaa5) (also LF) | 99 | MIA · 2025 Finest · Arm accuracy 97% · Arm strength 94% |  |
| 43 | [Ted Simmons](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/hall-of-fame-ted-simmons-7deebdf7) (also C) | 99 | STL · Hall of Fame · Reaction 83% · Arm strength 78% | 32,000 |
| 44 | [Anthony Santander](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/captain-anthony-santander-440fd543) (also RF) | 99 | TOR · Captain · Fielding 79% · Arm accuracy 77% |  |
| 45 | [Josh Naylor](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/2025-postseason-josh-naylor-6b369818) | 99 | SEA · 2025 Postseason · Arm strength 78% · Fielding 77% |  |
| 46 | [Cam Devanney](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/topps-now-cam-devanney-f35d2eba) (also 3B) | 97 | PIT · Topps Now · Arm accuracy 79% · Reaction 76% | 18,999 |
| 47 | [Vladimir Guerrero Jr.](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/2025-postseason-vladimir-guerrero-jr-da330e02) | 99 | TOR · 2025 Postseason · Arm strength 78% · Fielding 75% |  |
| 48 | [Gil Hodges](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/hall-of-fame-gil-hodges-65c6f9e2) | 99 | LAD · Hall of Fame · Fielding 85% · Reaction 80% |  |
| 49 | [Kyle Farmer](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/summer-kyle-farmer-0ff7d742) (also 2B) | 90 | COL · Summer · Reaction 87% · Fielding 86% |  |
| 50 | [Charlie Condon](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/neon-charlie-condon-187d4fa5) | 99 | COL · Neon · Arm strength 84% · Arm accuracy 75% |  |
| 51 | [Carlos Cortes](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/topps-now-carlos-cortes-2c77e133) (also RF) | 96 | OAK · Topps Now · Arm accuracy 91% · Arm strength 82% | 36,599 |
| 52 | [Salvador Perez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/prime-salvador-perez-0109e4e4) (also C) | 94 | KC · Prime · Arm accuracy 75% · Fielding 73% |  |
| 53 | [Michael Cuddyer](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/home-run-derby-x-michael-cuddyer-f079b53b) (also LF) | 99 | NYM · Home Run Derby X · Arm strength 96% · Arm accuracy 94% |  |
| 54 | [Austin Riley](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/awards-austin-riley-1a495bc8) (also 3B) | 99 | ATL · Awards · Arm accuracy 79% · Arm strength 72% | 21,222 |
| 55 | [Jake Cronenworth](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/color-storm-jake-cronenworth-cde10036) (also 2B) | 92 | SD · Color Storm · Fielding 86% · Reaction 85% |  |
| 56 | [Lou Gehrig](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/neon-lou-gehrig-a7fd98b4) | 99 | NYY · Neon · Fielding 81% · Reaction 76% |  |
| 57 | [Freddie Freeman](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/2025-postseason-freddie-freeman-4ed81cbf) | 99 | LAD · 2025 Postseason · Arm accuracy 99% · Fielding 77% |  |
| 58 | [Samuel Basallo](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/topps-now-samuel-basallo-39f95c42) (also C) | 97 | BAL · Topps Now · Arm strength 90% · Arm accuracy 88% |  |
| 59 | [Lance Berkman](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/neon-lance-berkman-ee7829c8) | 99 | HOU · Neon · Arm accuracy 88% · Fielding 70% |  |
| 60 | [Sal Stewart](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/topps-now-sal-stewart-7dccb5c7) (also 3B) | 97 | CIN · Topps Now · Arm strength 85% · Arm accuracy 77% |  |
| 61 | [Anthony Rizzo](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/neon-anthony-rizzo-5a390e19) | 99 | CHC · Neon · Fielding 91% · Reaction 83% |  |
| 62 | [Tony Perez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/captain-tony-perez-af0b3f7f) (also 3B) | 99 | CIN · Captain · Fielding 75% · Reaction 70% |  |
| 63 | [Jake Bauers](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/2025-postseason-jake-bauers-912a9681) | 99 | MIL · 2025 Postseason · Reaction 81% · Arm accuracy 71% |  |
| 64 | [Hunter Goodman](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/2025-finest-hunter-goodman-dbbec1b6) (also C) | 99 | COL · 2025 Finest · Arm strength 82% · Reaction 81% | 110,000 |
| 65 | [Gavin Fien](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/2025-draft-gavin-fien-51c475fd) (also 3B) | 97 | TEX · 2025 Draft · Arm strength 85% · Arm accuracy 79% | 98,887 |
| 66 | [Ryan O'Hearn](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/new-threads-ryan-o-hearn-8bfc4b71) | 98 | SD · New Threads · Reaction 92% · Fielding 91% | 6,500 |
| 67 | [Michael Young](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/spooky-michael-young-37e44bea) (also SS) | 99 | TEX · Spooky · Arm accuracy 80% · Arm strength 78% |  |
| 68 | [Brendan Donovan](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/2025-all-star-brendan-donovan-5e3e9296) (also 2B) | 96 | STL · 2025 All-Star · Arm accuracy 83% · Arm strength 69% |  |
| 69 | [Warming Bernabel](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/spotlight-warming-bernabel-94155bf2) | 99 | COL · Spotlight · Fielding 73% · Arm accuracy 71% | 39,000 |
| 70 | [Vinnie Pasquantino](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/spotlight-vinnie-pasquantino-67872cae) | 93 | KC · Spotlight · Fielding 89% · Reaction 81% | 28,896 |
| 71 | [Whit Merrifield](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/breakout-whit-merrifield-eb2cd22e) (also 2B) | 90 | KC · Breakout · Fielding 81% · Reaction 67% |  |
| 72 | [Max Muncy](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/2025-postseason-max-muncy-cc027da7) (also 3B) | 99 | LAD · 2025 Postseason · Arm strength 75% · Arm accuracy 71% |  |
| 73 | [Hank Greenberg](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/hall-of-fame-hank-greenberg-aa85b9dd) | 99 | DET · Hall of Fame · Fielding 75% · Reaction 67% |  |
| 74 | [Matt Olson](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/2025-all-star-matt-olson-0580ec5e) | 96 | ATL · 2025 All-Star · Fielding 89% · Reaction 80% |  |
| 75 | [Spencer Horwitz](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/spotlight-spencer-horwitz-d11b5ada) | 99 | PIT · Spotlight · Reaction 80% · Fielding 79% |  |
| 76 | [Alec Bohm](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/2025-postseason-alec-bohm-e8021a13) (also 3B) | 99 | PHI · 2025 Postseason · Arm accuracy 77% · Fielding 67% |  |
| 77 | [Rafael Palmeiro](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/standout-rafael-palmeiro-2c9bdff0) | 91 | TEX · Standout · Fielding 79% · Reaction 67% | 6,745 |
| 78 | [Bryce Harper](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/2025-finest-bryce-harper-37222b4b) | 99 | PHI · 2025 Finest · Arm accuracy 83% · Fielding 77% |  |
| 79 | [Dick Allen](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/hall-of-fame-dick-allen-e4854c56) (also 3B) | 99 | PHI · Hall of Fame · Arm strength 87% · Arm accuracy 83% |  |
| 80 | [Romy Gonzalez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/spotlight-romy-gonzalez-41abd53e) (also 2B) | 99 | BOS · Spotlight · Arm accuracy 80% · Reaction 76% | 44,444 |
| 81 | [Ethan Conrad](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/2025-draft-ethan-conrad-2c9ef150) (also CF) | 97 | CHC · 2025 Draft · Fielding 67% · Arm strength 65% |  |
| 82 | [Paul Molitor](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/hall-of-fame-paul-molitor-6c528267) (also 3B) | 99 | MIL · Hall of Fame · Reaction 73% · Arm accuracy 65% | 286,000 |
| 83 | [Rod Carew](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/hall-of-fame-rod-carew-b4d585f9) (also 2B) | 99 | MIN · Hall of Fame · Arm accuracy 71% · Fielding 70% | 112,000 |
| 84 | [Andrew Vaughn](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/2025-postseason-andrew-vaughn-7a48a717) | 99 | MIL · 2025 Postseason · Fielding 79% · Reaction 73% |  |
| 85 | [Mike Piazza](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/hall-of-fame-mike-piazza-a9f9ef04) (also C) | 99 | NYM · Hall of Fame · Arm strength 69% · Fielding 65% | 63,997 |
| 86 | [Willson Contreras](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/spotlight-willson-contreras-2bbaa0aa) | 91 | STL · Spotlight · Arm strength 88% · Arm accuracy 68% | 28,811 |
| 87 | [Tyler Soderstrom](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/neon-tyler-soderstrom-026a5e0e) (also LF) | 99 | OAK · Neon · Arm strength 91% · Arm accuracy 71% |  |
| 88 | [Yandy Díaz](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/2025-finest-yandy-diaz-3dd8d2d7) | 99 | TB · 2025 Finest · Arm accuracy 95% · Reaction 73% |  |
| 89 | [Casey Schmitt](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/spotlight-casey-schmitt-528cf8c4) (also 3B) | 94 | SF · Spotlight · Arm strength 85% · Arm accuracy 71% | 24,999 |
| 90 | [Bryce Eldridge](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/topps-now-bryce-eldridge-83c12dcd) | 97 | SF · Topps Now · Arm strength 85% · Arm accuracy 65% | 25,000 |
| 91 | [Raul Ibanez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/cornerstone-raul-ibanez-3324deab) (also LF) | 97 | SEA · Cornerstone · Arm strength 69% · Arm accuracy 68% |  |
| 92 | [Luis Arraez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/captain-luis-arraez-80de47d7) | 99 | SD · Captain · Arm accuracy 96% · Arm strength 57% |  |
| 93 | [Carlos Pena](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/moonshot-carlos-pena-99af359a) | 99 | TB · Moonshot · Arm accuracy 91% · Arm strength 69% |  |
| 94 | [Mike Napoli](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/prime-mike-napoli-4cd6833a) (also C) | 99 | LAA · Prime · Arm accuracy 71% · Arm strength 65% | 130,000 |
| 95 | [Dalton Rushing](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/topps-now-dalton-rushing-3ff00a46) (also C) | 90 | LAD · Topps Now · Arm strength 65% · Arm accuracy 61% | 63,207 |
| 96 | [Justin Morneau](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/signature-justin-morneau-32096261) | 98 | MIN · Signature · Fielding 73% · Reaction 73% |  |
| 97 | [Michael Busch](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/2025-postseason-michael-busch-74c08d99) | 99 | CHC · 2025 Postseason · Arm accuracy 95% · Fielding 63% |  |
| 98 | [Daniel Murphy](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/home-run-derby-x-daniel-murphy-100753d0) (also 2B) | 99 | NYM · Home Run Derby X · Arm accuracy 68% · Fielding 63% |  |
| 99 | [Kris Bryant](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/standout-kris-bryant-3abd04d5) (also 3B) | 90 | CHC · Standout · Arm strength 75% · Reaction 64% |  |
| 100 | [Bobby Seymour](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/cards/topps-now-bobby-seymour-45f72af4) | 97 | TB · Topps Now · Fielding 73% · Reaction 67% | 27,965 |

## Other positions

- [catchers](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/best/glove/c)
- [second basemen](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/best/glove/2b)
- [third basemen](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/best/glove/3b)
- [shortstops](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/best/glove/ss)
- [left fielders](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/best/glove/lf)
- [center fielders](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/best/glove/cf)
- [right fielders](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb25/best/glove/rf)
