# Best plate-discipline shortstops

> The best plate-discipline shortstops in MLB 24, ranked against every card eligible there, with live Community Market prices.

Canonical: https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/best/eye/ss

Works the count and refuses to chase.

167 cards ranked

**Ranked on:** Plate discipline 42% · Plate vision 30% · Contact vs R 17% · Contact vs L 11%. Ranked among cards rated 90 overall and above — below that the order is simply the overall rating again.

| # | Card | OVR | Why | Buy now |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 1 | [Jackie Robinson](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/hall-of-fame-jackie-robinson-6e03a392) (also 2B) | 99 | LAD · Hall of Fame · Plate vision 100% · Contact vs R 98% |  |
| 2 | [Gunnar Henderson](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/topps-now-gunnar-henderson-07a67ed4) | 99 | BAL · Topps Now · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs R 98% |  |
| 3 | [Michael Young](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/action-figure-michael-young-11aa628a) | 99 | TEX · Action Figure · Contact vs R 98% · Plate vision 98% |  |
| 4 | [Elly De La Cruz](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/topps-now-elly-de-la-cruz-d7f05f85) | 99 | CIN · Topps Now · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs R 98% |  |
| 5 | [Mookie Betts](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/season-awards-mookie-betts-9fd78e7f) | 99 | LAD · Season Awards · Contact vs L 97% · Plate vision 95% |  |
| 6 | [Ketel Marte](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-finest-ketel-marte-87e5534d) (also 2B) | 99 | ARI · 2024 Finest · Contact vs L 97% · Plate vision 96% |  |
| 7 | [Luis Arraez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/topps-now-luis-arraez-2ff14580) (also 2B) | 96 | SD · Topps Now · Plate vision 100% · Contact vs R 98% |  |
| 8 | [Ozzie Smith](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/action-figure-ozzie-smith-13427c34) | 99 | STL · Action Figure · Plate vision 100% · Contact vs R 98% | 27,999 |
| 9 | [Corey Seager](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/the-show-classics-corey-seager-26168ad3) | 99 | TEX · The Show Classics · Plate vision 98% · Contact vs R 98% | 329,999 |
| 10 | [Xavier Edwards](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/season-awards-xavier-edwards-05e71e92) | 99 | MIA · Season Awards · Contact vs R 98% · Contact vs L 97% | 10,000 |
| 11 | [Will Wagner](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/topps-now-will-wagner-a76b4280) (also 2B) | 98 | TOR · Topps Now · Plate vision 94% · Contact vs L 93% |  |
| 12 | [Jackson Holliday](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/pipeline-jackson-holliday-df0643b0) | 99 | BAL · Pipeline · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs R 98% |  |
| 13 | [Carlos Correa](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/captain-carlos-correa-44cc6099) | 99 | MIN · Captain · Plate vision 94% · Contact vs R 93% |  |
| 14 | [Travis Bazzana](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-draft-travis-bazzana-607da1be) (also 2B) | 99 | CLE · 2024 Draft · Plate discipline 96% · Contact vs R 92% | 19,999 |
| 15 | [Barry Larkin](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/awards-barry-larkin-87d134ad) | 99 | CIN · Awards · Plate vision 96% · Plate discipline 95% | 38,994 |
| 16 | [Gleyber Torres](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-postseason-gleyber-torres-1d7cbd82) (also 2B) | 99 | NYY · 2024 Postseason · Contact vs R 95% · Plate vision 91% |  |
| 17 | [Bobby Witt Jr.](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-finest-bobby-witt-jr-eacae450) | 99 | KC · 2024 Finest · Contact vs R 98% · Contact vs L 97% |  |
| 18 | [Spencer Steer](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-finest-spencer-steer-5e97aadb) (also LF) | 99 | CIN · 2024 Finest · Plate discipline 96% · Plate vision 91% |  |
| 19 | [Kristian Campbell](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/awards-kristian-campbell-ae283e04) (also 2B) | 99 | BOS · Awards · Contact vs R 98% · Contact vs L 97% |  |
| 20 | [JJ Wetherholt](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-draft-jj-wetherholt-80869551) | 97 | STL · 2024 Draft · Plate discipline 98% · Plate vision 86% | 13,333 |
| 21 | [Derek Jeter](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/hall-of-fame-derek-jeter-e05ada5c) | 99 | NYY · Hall of Fame · Contact vs R 98% · Contact vs L 97% |  |
| 22 | [Willy Adames](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-finest-willy-adames-6f0956fa) | 99 | MIL · 2024 Finest · Plate discipline 96% · Contact vs R 94% |  |
| 23 | [River Ryan](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/out-of-position-river-ryan-ac6ee3be) | 97 | LAD · Out of Position · Contact vs R 98% · Contact vs L 97% | 8,880 |
| 24 | [Rap Dixon](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/jin-kim-rap-dixon-9a1d3ee7) (also RF) | 99 | FA · Jin Kim · Plate vision 92% · Contact vs R 92% | 10,320 |
| 25 | [Brice Turang](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/milestone-brice-turang-388ad82d) (also 2B) | 99 | MIL · Milestone · Plate vision 98% · Plate discipline 87% |  |
| 26 | [Jurickson Profar](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/season-awards-jurickson-profar-dd73947a) (also LF) | 99 | SD · Season Awards · Contact vs R 94% · Plate vision 90% |  |
| 27 | [Hank Thompson](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/jin-kim-hank-thompson-216d8167) (also RF) | 99 | FA · Jin Kim · Plate vision 92% · Contact vs R 90% | 18,000 |
| 28 | [Mike Schmidt](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/milestone-mike-schmidt-ad0d397c) (also 3B) | 99 | PHI · Milestone · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs L 90% |  |
| 29 | [Marcelo Mayer](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/pipeline-marcelo-mayer-deedcd3e) | 99 | BOS · Pipeline · Plate discipline 92% · Contact vs L 89% | 25,788 |
| 30 | [Garrett Hampson](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-postseason-garrett-hampson-5951680e) (also CF) | 99 | KC · 2024 Postseason · Contact vs L 97% · Plate vision 95% |  |
| 31 | [Matt Chapman](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-finest-matt-chapman-8df1ec86) (also 3B) | 99 | SF · 2024 Finest · Plate discipline 93% · Plate vision 88% |  |
| 32 | [Marcus Semien](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/finest-marcus-semien-ad6bb152) (also 2B) | 99 | TOR · Finest · Plate vision 94% · Contact vs R 87% | 188,888 |
| 33 | [Bo Bichette](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/finest-bo-bichette-f5d4ff31) | 99 | TOR · Finest · Plate vision 100% · Contact vs R 98% | 21,999 |
| 34 | [Anthony Volpe](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-postseason-anthony-volpe-83ce1e0e) | 99 | NYY · 2024 Postseason · Contact vs L 93% · Contact vs R 92% |  |
| 35 | [Kellon Lindsey](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-draft-kellon-lindsey-60967da7) | 95 | LAD · 2024 Draft · Plate discipline 95% · Plate vision 89% |  |
| 36 | [Colson Montgomery](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/pipeline-colson-montgomery-69bbc4cc) | 99 | CWS · Pipeline · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs R 81% | 12,500 |
| 37 | [Alan Trammell](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/hyper-alan-trammell-dc5d87d4) | 99 | DET · Hyper · Plate vision 91% · Contact vs L 91% |  |
| 38 | [Nick Yorke](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/topps-now-nick-yorke-c3e89357) (also 2B) | 97 | PIT · Topps Now · Contact vs R 98% · Plate discipline 84% |  |
| 39 | [José Altuve](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/captain-jose-altuve-cbb66093) (also 2B) | 99 | HOU · Captain · Contact vs L 97% · Plate vision 97% |  |
| 40 | [Brad Miller](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/hyper-brad-miller-14aa26e1) | 99 | TB · Hyper · Plate vision 89% · Contact vs R 85% |  |
| 41 | [Brandon Crawford](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/action-figure-brandon-crawford-76d790cf) | 99 | SF · Action Figure · Contact vs R 98% · Plate vision 85% |  |
| 42 | [Ernie Banks](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/action-figure-ernie-banks-994f5d1c) | 99 | CHC · Action Figure · Contact vs L 97% · Plate vision 97% |  |
| 43 | [Troy Glaus](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/finest-troy-glaus-ebbe808b) (also 3B) | 99 | LAA · Finest · Plate discipline 98% · Plate vision 80% |  |
| 44 | [Mark Vientos](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-postseason-mark-vientos-7c2024f5) (also 3B) | 99 | NYM · 2024 Postseason · Contact vs L 92% · Plate discipline 89% |  |
| 45 | [Kutter Crawford](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/out-of-position-kutter-crawford-6a3496bc) | 95 | BOS · Out of Position · Contact vs R 88% · Plate vision 88% |  |
| 46 | [Andy Ibáñez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-postseason-andy-ibanez-302d81c3) (also 3B) | 99 | DET · 2024 Postseason · Plate vision 98% · Contact vs L 97% |  |
| 47 | [José Ramírez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-finest-jose-ramirez-cd2d84f4) (also 3B) | 99 | CLE · 2024 Finest · Plate vision 98% · Contact vs L 97% |  |
| 48 | [Nick Sogard](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/topps-now-nick-sogard-a256dfbc) (also 2B) | 98 | BOS · Topps Now · Contact vs R 93% · Plate discipline 84% | 9,799 |
| 49 | [Nacho Alvarez Jr.](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/topps-now-nacho-alvarez-jr-aefde71b) (also 3B) | 97 | ATL · Topps Now · Contact vs R 93% · Plate vision 91% |  |
| 50 | [Brian Roberts](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/hyper-brian-roberts-7d75012d) (also 2B) | 99 | BAL · Hyper · Contact vs R 98% · Plate vision 89% |  |
| 51 | [Jonathan India](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/season-awards-jonathan-india-62c9de9a) (also 2B) | 94 | CIN · Season Awards · Contact vs L 88% · Plate discipline 86% |  |
| 52 | [Francisco Lindor](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-postseason-francisco-lindor-cc0fafe2) | 99 | NYM · 2024 Postseason · Contact vs R 95% · Plate vision 89% |  |
| 53 | [Alex Bregman](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-finest-alex-bregman-ff13ef95) (also 3B) | 99 | HOU · 2024 Finest · Plate vision 98% · Contact vs R 93% |  |
| 54 | [Enrique Hernández](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-postseason-enrique-hernandez-557aa9c9) (also CF) | 99 | LAD · 2024 Postseason · Plate vision 96% · Contact vs R 88% |  |
| 55 | [Isaac Paredes](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-all-star-isaac-paredes-8ba2bf61) (also 3B) | 95 | TB · 2024 All-Star · Plate vision 89% · Contact vs L 87% |  |
| 56 | [Rich Aurilia](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/action-figure-rich-aurilia-11b0674b) | 99 | SF · Action Figure · Contact vs L 97% · Plate vision 96% |  |
| 57 | [Jorge Polanco](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/finest-jorge-polanco-9a876248) (also 2B) | 99 | MIN · Finest · Plate vision 94% · Contact vs L 88% |  |
| 58 | [Cal Ripken Jr.](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/action-figure-cal-ripken-jr-9255c590) | 99 | BAL · Action Figure · Plate vision 99% · Contact vs L 97% |  |
| 59 | [Josh H. Smith](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/topps-now-josh-h-smith-4904f82c) (also LF) | 98 | TEX · Topps Now · Plate vision 88% · Contact vs L 87% | 8,500 |
| 60 | [Bryson Stott](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/hyper-bryson-stott-1d5a8f3f) (also 2B) | 99 | PHI · Hyper · Plate vision 87% · Plate discipline 84% | 22,000 |
| 61 | [Zach Neto](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/topps-now-zach-neto-16a21259) | 99 | LAA · Topps Now · Contact vs L 97% · Plate vision 91% |  |
| 62 | [Brooks Robinson](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/action-figure-brooks-robinson-51b4b5e9) (also 3B) | 99 | BAL · Action Figure · Plate vision 98% · Contact vs L 97% | 24,996 |
| 63 | [Cam Smith](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-draft-cam-smith-406a93ea) (also 3B) | 95 | CHC · 2024 Draft · Plate discipline 88% · Plate vision 79% | 12,000 |
| 64 | [Jett Williams](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/pipeline-jett-williams-003f23cd) | 96 | NYM · Pipeline · Plate discipline 95% · Contact vs R 75% | 8,000 |
| 65 | [Romy Gonzalez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/topps-now-romy-gonzalez-07c09ba3) (also 1B) | 96 | BOS · Topps Now · Contact vs L 97% · Contact vs R 91% |  |
| 66 | [Carson Williams](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/awards-carson-williams-0493c439) | 99 | TB · Awards · Plate discipline 88% · Contact vs L 86% |  |
| 67 | [Tommy Edman](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-postseason-tommy-edman-5d88c05e) | 99 | LAD · 2024 Postseason · Contact vs L 97% · Plate vision 91% |  |
| 68 | [Eugenio Suarez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/prime-eugenio-suarez-9bd6e242) (also 3B) | 99 | CIN · Prime · Plate discipline 89% · Contact vs L 81% |  |
| 69 | [Justin Turner](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/action-figure-justin-turner-8186fb41) (also 3B) | 99 | LAD · Action Figure · Contact vs L 97% · Plate vision 94% |  |
| 70 | [Bret Saberhagen](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/out-of-position-bret-saberhagen-6000e1d4) | 97 | KC · Out of Position · Plate vision 90% · Contact vs L 88% | 11,555 |
| 71 | [Wenceel Perez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/topps-now-wenceel-perez-57b78a8f) (also RF) | 96 | DET · Topps Now · Plate discipline 85% · Contact vs L 84% | 7,000 |
| 72 | [Honus Wagner](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/milestone-honus-wagner-277e8394) | 99 | PIT · Milestone · Plate vision 98% · Contact vs L 89% | 177,777 |
| 73 | [Jacob deGrom](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/out-of-position-jacob-degrom-dfcb89d6) | 95 | NYM · Out of Position · Plate vision 91% · Contact vs R 79% |  |
| 74 | [Manny Machado](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/captain-manny-machado-eadc231b) (also 3B) | 99 | SD · Captain · Plate vision 92% · Contact vs R 84% |  |
| 75 | [Aidan Miller](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/pipeline-aidan-miller-3e8654a2) (also 3B) | 98 | PHI · Pipeline · Plate discipline 90% · Contact vs L 80% | 11,111 |
| 76 | [Angel Martinez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/topps-now-angel-martinez-8594af4b) (also LF) | 95 | CLE · Topps Now · Contact vs L 87% · Plate discipline 83% |  |
| 77 | [Brooks Lee](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/pipeline-brooks-lee-9b84c2b4) | 97 | MIN · Pipeline · Contact vs R 92% · Plate vision 86% | 7,200 |
| 78 | [Vinny Castilla](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/milestone-vinny-castilla-0c30a631) (also 3B) | 99 | COL · Milestone · Plate vision 95% · Contact vs L 87% | 12,500 |
| 79 | [Otto Lopez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-finest-otto-lopez-de1c8383) (also 2B) | 99 | MIA · 2024 Finest · Contact vs R 98% · Plate vision 98% |  |
| 80 | [Jeremy Peña](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/captain-jeremy-pena-22adc7ca) | 99 | HOU · Captain · Contact vs L 97% · Plate vision 95% |  |
| 81 | [Fernando Tatis Jr.](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-all-star-fernando-tatis-jr-31d37530) (also RF) | 99 | SD · 2024 All-Star · Contact vs R 91% · Contact vs L 79% |  |
| 82 | [Kaelen Culpepper](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-draft-kaelen-culpepper-9140ff62) | 95 | MIN · 2024 Draft · Contact vs L 79% · Plate vision 78% |  |
| 83 | [Niko Goodrum](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/the-show-classics-niko-goodrum-399ca2ca) | 97 | DET · The Show Classics · Contact vs L 97% · Plate discipline 85% | 7,200 |
| 84 | [Luis García](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-finest-luis-garcia-84a34c9c) (also 2B) | 99 | WAS · 2024 Finest · Plate vision 99% · Contact vs R 98% |  |
| 85 | [Alfonso Soriano](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/finest-alfonso-soriano-029e23f1) (also 2B) | 99 | NYY · Finest · Plate vision 94% · Contact vs L 93% | 38,500 |
| 86 | [Dansby Swanson](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/captain-dansby-swanson-0f25fb40) | 99 | ATL · Captain · Contact vs L 89% · Contact vs R 82% |  |
| 87 | [Trea Turner](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-finest-trea-turner-a4ae4b5c) | 99 | PHI · 2024 Finest · Contact vs L 97% · Plate vision 95% |  |
| 88 | [Theo Gillen](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-draft-theo-gillen-60e43a4b) (also CF) | 95 | TB · 2024 Draft · Contact vs R 83% · Plate discipline 81% | 13,000 |
| 89 | [Eugenio Suárez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/captain-eugenio-suarez-fdc92c71) (also 3B) | 99 | CIN · Captain · Plate discipline 91% · Contact vs L 72% |  |
| 90 | [Jimmy Rollins](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/milestone-jimmy-rollins-7814d6c5) | 99 | PHI · Milestone · Plate vision 98% · Contact vs L 92% |  |
| 91 | [Austin Martin](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/topps-now-austin-martin-23ddd1e7) (also CF) | 91 | MIN · Topps Now · Plate vision 84% · Contact vs R 79% | 9,000 |
| 92 | [Luis Rengifo](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/the-show-classics-luis-rengifo-4da0ac7c) | 98 | LAA · The Show Classics · Contact vs L 97% · Plate vision 89% | 8,450 |
| 93 | [Zac Gallen](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/out-of-position-zac-gallen-be5d7d51) | 95 | ARI · Out of Position · Plate vision 92% · Contact vs R 73% |  |
| 94 | [Leo Jimenez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/topps-now-leo-jimenez-535ed657) (also 2B) | 91 | TOR · Topps Now · Plate discipline 81% · Plate vision 72% |  |
| 95 | [Jazz Chisholm Jr.](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/topps-now-jazz-chisholm-jr-38fcf18b) (also CF) | 98 | NYY · Topps Now · Contact vs L 81% · Plate discipline 77% | 38,436 |
| 96 | [Christian Moore](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-draft-christian-moore-4f32d928) (also 2B) | 97 | LAA · 2024 Draft · Plate vision 84% · Contact vs L 75% | 15,900 |
| 97 | [Nick Gonzales](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/topps-now-nick-gonzales-c1a1d4db) (also 2B) | 97 | PIT · Topps Now · Contact vs R 87% · Contact vs L 87% | 12,221 |
| 98 | [Jackson Merrill](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/2024-finest-jackson-merrill-50ca74fd) (also CF) | 99 | SD · 2024 Finest · Contact vs R 98% · Plate vision 95% |  |
| 99 | [Trevor Story](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/prime-trevor-story-05984c54) | 99 | COL · Prime · Contact vs L 89% · Plate discipline 78% | 13,000 |
| 100 | [Robin Yount](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/cards/hyper-robin-yount-4163e013) | 99 | MIL · Hyper · Contact vs L 97% · Plate vision 95% |  |

## Other positions

- [catchers](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/best/eye/c)
- [first basemen](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/best/eye/1b)
- [second basemen](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/best/eye/2b)
- [third basemen](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/best/eye/3b)
- [left fielders](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/best/eye/lf)
- [center fielders](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/best/eye/cf)
- [right fielders](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb24/best/eye/rf)
