# Best plate-discipline first basemen

> The best plate-discipline first basemen in MLB 23, ranked against every card eligible there, with live Community Market prices.

Canonical: https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/best/eye/1b

Works the count and refuses to chase.

267 cards ranked

**Ranked on:** Plate discipline 42% · Plate vision 30% · Contact vs R 17% · Contact vs L 11%. Ranked among cards rated 90 overall and above — below that the order is simply the overall rating again.

| # | Card | OVR | Why | Buy now |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 1 | [George Brett](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-george-brett-147aabaf) (also 3B) | 99 | KC · Finest · Plate vision 99% · Plate discipline 98% |  |
| 2 | [Keith Hernandez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-keith-hernandez-1e810463) | 99 | NYM · Finest · Plate vision 99% · Plate discipline 98% | 34,400 |
| 3 | [Wade Boggs](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-wade-boggs-f9ded756) (also 3B) | 99 | NYY · Finest · Plate vision 99% · Plate discipline 98% | 34,475 |
| 4 | [Babe Ruth](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/milestone-babe-ruth-624d41a9) (also RF) | 99 | NYY · Milestone · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs R 97% |  |
| 5 | [Larry Doby](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-larry-doby-26d07ae4) (also CF) | 99 | CLE · Finest · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs R 97% |  |
| 6 | [Adley Rutschman](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/2023-all-star-adley-rutschman-045a55c4) (also C) | 99 | BAL · 2023 All-Star · Plate discipline 98% · Plate vision 97% |  |
| 7 | [Jackie Robinson](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/jin-kim-jackie-robinson-7626051f) (also SS) | 99 | FA · Jin Kim · Plate vision 99% · Contact vs R 97% |  |
| 8 | [Luis Arraez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/monthly-awards-luis-arraez-2b2f5860) (also 2B) | 98 | MIA · Monthly Awards · Plate vision 99% · Contact vs R 97% |  |
| 9 | [Vladimir Guerrero Jr.](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/topps-now-vladimir-guerrero-jr-5b2fa35f) | 99 | TOR · Topps Now · Plate vision 99% · Contact vs L 96% |  |
| 10 | [Johnny Damon](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-johnny-damon-c4f5429e) (also LF) | 99 | NYY · Finest · Plate vision 99% · Contact vs R 97% | 68,900 |
| 11 | [Bryce Harper](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/2023-finest-bryce-harper-b2433c61) | 99 | PHI · 2023 Finest · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs R 92% | 179,000 |
| 12 | [Joe Torre](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-joe-torre-e364d852) (also 3B) | 99 | STL · Finest · Plate vision 99% · Contact vs R 97% |  |
| 13 | [Rod Carew](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/charisma-rod-carew-f6f0bb7d) (also 2B) | 99 | MIN · Charisma · Plate vision 99% · Contact vs R 97% | 34,999 |
| 14 | [Matt Carpenter](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/signature-matt-carpenter-f4f0db41) (also 3B) | 99 | STL · Signature · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs R 94% | 349,900 |
| 15 | [Ralph Kiner](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/prime-ralph-kiner-76400c75) (also LF) | 99 | PIT · Prime · Plate discipline 98% · Plate vision 96% | 31,479 |
| 16 | [Todd Helton](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-todd-helton-04dc6557) | 99 | COL · Finest · Contact vs R 97% · Plate discipline 96% |  |
| 17 | [Carlos Santana](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/signature-carlos-santana-b1411553) | 99 | CLE · Signature · Plate discipline 98% · Plate vision 96% | 342,500 |
| 18 | [Kyle Schwarber](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/2023-postseason-kyle-schwarber-d0e5d77a) (also DH) | 99 | PHI · 2023 Postseason · Plate discipline 98% · Plate vision 92% |  |
| 19 | [Nolan Schanuel](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/2023-finest-nolan-schanuel-665d34fa) | 97 | LAA · 2023 Finest · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs R 97% | 35,000 |
| 20 | [Miguel Cabrera](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/signature-miguel-cabrera-1db2d761) | 99 | DET · Signature · Contact vs R 97% · Contact vs L 96% |  |
| 21 | [Chicken Man](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/incognito-chicken-man-08cc5f2a) (also 3B) | 96 | BOS · Incognito · Contact vs R 97% · Plate vision 93% |  |
| 22 | [Buck O'Neil](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/jin-kim-buck-o-neil-f51f6d91) | 99 | FA · Jin Kim · Contact vs L 96% · Contact vs R 93% | 30,068 |
| 23 | [Joe Mauer](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/kaiju-joe-mauer-5fd56c1f) (also C) | 99 | MIN · Kaiju · Contact vs R 97% · Contact vs L 96% | 200,000 |
| 24 | [Ken Griffey Sr.](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-ken-griffey-sr-4a36d9f1) (also RF) | 99 | CIN · Finest · Contact vs R 97% · Plate vision 96% |  |
| 25 | [Rafael Devers](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/awards-rafael-devers-799986da) (also 3B) | 99 | BOS · Awards · Contact vs R 93% · Plate vision 92% | 82,900 |
| 26 | [RedTurn2](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/incognito-redturn2-3e37f888) (also 3B) | 99 | LAD · Incognito · Plate vision 97% · Contact vs L 96% | 65,900 |
| 27 | [The Big Hurt](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/incognito-the-big-hurt-6af90263) | 99 | CWS · Incognito · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs L 90% | 209,900 |
| 28 | [Yandy Diaz](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/2023-finest-yandy-diaz-c7908117) | 99 | TB · 2023 Finest · Contact vs R 97% · Contact vs L 96% |  |
| 29 | [Mark McGwire](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/great-race-of-98-mark-mcgwire-bf09e894) | 99 | STL · Great Race of '98 · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs R 97% |  |
| 30 | [David Justice](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/great-race-of-98-david-justice-a29d77f0) (also LF) | 97 | CLE · Great Race of '98 · Plate discipline 95% · Contact vs R 92% | 24,850 |
| 31 | [Austin Riley](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/2023-all-star-austin-riley-4b7a2cf0) (also 3B) | 99 | ATL · 2023 All-Star · Plate vision 94% · Contact vs R 92% |  |
| 32 | [Paul Goldschmidt](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/2023-finest-paul-goldschmidt-db19900c) | 99 | STL · 2023 Finest · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs L 96% | 74,900 |
| 33 | [Luis Gonzalez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/great-race-of-98-luis-gonzalez-1e1b9769) (also LF) | 99 | DET · Great Race of '98 · Plate vision 99% · Contact vs L 89% | 18,499 |
| 34 | [Kevin Youkilis](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-kevin-youkilis-b31c7f46) | 99 | BOS · Finest · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs R 91% |  |
| 35 | [Cody Bellinger](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/monthly-awards-cody-bellinger-8064e1c8) (also CF) | 99 | CHC · Monthly Awards · Contact vs R 97% · Contact vs L 96% |  |
| 36 | [Matt Holliday](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-matt-holliday-6c479a8a) (also LF) | 99 | STL · Finest · Contact vs R 97% · Contact vs L 96% |  |
| 37 | [Nathaniel Lowe](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/2023-finest-nathaniel-lowe-356e29f3) | 99 | TEX · 2023 Finest · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs R 97% |  |
| 38 | [Mike Napoli](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-mike-napoli-2b9cb28c) (also C) | 99 | TEX · Finest · Plate discipline 95% · Contact vs R 92% |  |
| 39 | [Joey Votto](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/snapshot-joey-votto-8a69b960) | 99 | CIN · Snapshot · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs R 97% |  |
| 40 | [Stan The Man](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/incognito-stan-the-man-27d212d8) (also RF) | 99 | STL · Incognito · Plate vision 98% · Contact vs R 97% | 59,000 |
| 41 | [Kensuke Kondoh](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/world-baseball-classic-kensuke-kondoh-d0d486f0) (also RF) | 97 | FA · World Baseball Classic · Plate vision 96% · Plate discipline 90% |  |
| 42 | [Jimmie Foxx](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/milestone-jimmie-foxx-f11f6494) | 99 | OAK · Milestone · Contact vs R 97% · Plate discipline 96% |  |
| 43 | [Paul Konerko](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-paul-konerko-c20edeee) | 99 | CWS · Finest · Plate discipline 93% · Plate vision 90% | 27,789 |
| 44 | [Alex Gordon](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/awards-alex-gordon-7faa7ab7) (also LF) | 99 | KC · Awards · Contact vs R 91% · Plate discipline 90% | 29,800 |
| 45 | [Joc Pederson](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/home-run-derby-joc-pederson-d3635b07) (also CF) | 99 | LAD · Home Run Derby · Plate discipline 98% · Plate vision 85% | 30,000 |
| 46 | [Harmon Killebrew](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/signature-harmon-killebrew-e5f15cc6) | 99 | MIN · Signature · Plate discipline 98% · Plate vision 89% | 20,000 |
| 47 | [Andy Ibanez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/monthly-awards-andy-ibanez-130706ee) (also 2B) | 96 | DET · Monthly Awards · Contact vs R 97% · Contact vs L 96% |  |
| 48 | [Paul Molitor](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-paul-molitor-5e0a6ed1) (also 3B) | 99 | MIL · Finest · Plate vision 97% · Contact vs L 96% |  |
| 49 | [Stan Musial](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/kaiju-stan-musial-3c89308f) (also CF) | 90 | STL · Kaiju · Plate vision 95% · Contact vs R 89% |  |
| 50 | [Jason Giambi](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/great-race-of-98-jason-giambi-5bc77550) | 99 | OAK · Great Race of '98 · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs R 91% | 10,000 |
| 51 | [Nick Castellanos](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/2023-all-star-nick-castellanos-ee9af505) (also RF) | 99 | PHI · 2023 All-Star · Contact vs R 97% · Contact vs L 96% | 41,990 |
| 52 | [Freddie Freeman](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/2023-finest-freddie-freeman-c560897e) | 99 | LAD · 2023 Finest · Contact vs R 97% · Contact vs L 96% |  |
| 53 | [Orlando Cepeda](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/charisma-orlando-cepeda-d45409b3) | 99 | STL · Charisma · Contact vs R 97% · Contact vs L 96% |  |
| 54 | [Edgar Martinez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/great-race-of-98-edgar-martinez-3b92d6c1) (also DH) | 97 | SEA · Great Race of '98 · Plate discipline 95% · Contact vs R 87% | 24,989 |
| 55 | [G-Money](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/incognito-g-money-802d6a1f) | 99 | TB · Incognito · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs R 89% | 45,000 |
| 56 | [Jose Miranda](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/charisma-jose-miranda-cac029e0) (also 3B) | 97 | MIN · Charisma · Plate vision 98% · Plate discipline 89% |  |
| 57 | [The Ignitor](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/incognito-the-ignitor-6d739747) (also 3B) | 97 | MIL · Incognito · Contact vs R 97% · Contact vs L 87% |  |
| 58 | [Willie McCovey](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/all-star-game-willie-mccovey-a3afb61a) | 99 | SF · All-Star Game · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs R 85% | 21,500 |
| 59 | [Eddie Murray](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-eddie-murray-10806032) | 99 | BAL · Finest · Contact vs L 96% · Plate vision 94% |  |
| 60 | [Big Papi](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/incognito-big-papi-9037c8d6) | 99 | BOS · Incognito · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs R 97% |  |
| 61 | [Lou Gehrig](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/charisma-lou-gehrig-ed565472) | 99 | NYY · Charisma · Plate discipline 90% · Plate vision 89% | 77,700 |
| 62 | [Billy Williams](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-billy-williams-4ce7f495) (also RF) | 99 | CHC · Finest · Plate vision 97% · Contact vs L 96% |  |
| 63 | [Isaac Paredes](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/2023-finest-isaac-paredes-a1dbaf0b) (also 3B) | 99 | TB · 2023 Finest · Plate vision 89% · Plate discipline 87% |  |
| 64 | [Gary Carter](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/snapshot-gary-carter-5329896b) (also C) | 99 | NYM · Snapshot · Plate vision 97% · Contact vs L 96% | 62,500 |
| 65 | [Monte Irvin](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/captain-monte-irvin-6b1249e4) (also LF) | 95 | SF · Captain · Plate vision 95% · Plate discipline 86% |  |
| 66 | [Carlos Delgado](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/great-race-of-98-carlos-delgado-b611f058) | 99 | TOR · Great Race of '98 · Contact vs L 96% · Contact vs R 92% | 71,798 |
| 67 | [Jake Cronenworth](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-jake-cronenworth-83551df7) (also 2B) | 99 | SD · Finest · Plate vision 96% · Contact vs L 84% |  |
| 68 | [Brandon Belt](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-brandon-belt-d1138551) | 99 | SF · Finest · Contact vs R 97% · Contact vs L 89% |  |
| 69 | [Ryan Howard](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/home-run-derby-ryan-howard-58e25a23) | 99 | PHI · Home Run Derby · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs R 85% | 66,900 |
| 70 | [Raul Ibanez](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-raul-ibanez-f0d1e9fd) (also LF) | 99 | SEA · Finest · Contact vs R 97% · Plate vision 91% |  |
| 71 | [Nelson Cruz](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/home-run-derby-nelson-cruz-215b8dd1) (also RF) | 99 | TEX · Home Run Derby · Contact vs R 87% · Plate discipline 86% | 199,900 |
| 72 | [Gunnar Henderson](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/2023-finest-gunnar-henderson-02209226) (also SS) | 99 | BAL · 2023 Finest · Contact vs R 91% · Plate discipline 88% | 199,900 |
| 73 | [Frank Thomas](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/snapshot-frank-thomas-b986fd18) | 97 | CWS · Snapshot · Plate discipline 93% · Plate vision 87% |  |
| 74 | [Munetaka Murakami](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/world-baseball-classic-munetaka-murakami-d1d3e2f7) (also 3B) | 99 | FA · World Baseball Classic · Plate discipline 96% · Contact vs L 82% | 950,000 |
| 75 | [Miguel Sano](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/home-run-derby-miguel-sano-829553a5) (also 3B) | 99 | MIN · Home Run Derby · Plate discipline 91% · Contact vs L 90% | 49,995 |
| 76 | [Slamtana](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/incognito-slamtana-d38450fa) | 97 | CLE · Incognito · Plate discipline 92% · Contact vs L 91% | 24,000 |
| 77 | [Manny Machado](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/2023-finest-manny-machado-d91a16fc) (also 3B) | 99 | SD · 2023 Finest · Contact vs L 96% · Plate vision 93% |  |
| 78 | [Pavin Smith](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/2023-postseason-pavin-smith-f32151da) (also RF) | 97 | ARI · 2023 Postseason · Plate discipline 98% · Plate vision 82% |  |
| 79 | [Jim Thome](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-jim-thome-75d53bf2) (also DH) | 99 | MIN · Finest · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs R 97% |  |
| 80 | [Josh Bell](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/2023-postseason-josh-bell-30081355) | 99 | MIA · 2023 Postseason · Contact vs R 97% · Plate discipline 85% |  |
| 81 | [Pete Alonso](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/2023-finest-pete-alonso-2d1c29e7) | 99 | NYM · 2023 Finest · Plate discipline 89% · Plate vision 81% |  |
| 82 | [Tony Clark](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-tony-clark-0ea23eed) | 99 | DET · Finest · Plate discipline 96% · Contact vs R 80% |  |
| 83 | [Jorge Posada](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/milestone-jorge-posada-d838a873) (also C) | 97 | NYY · Milestone · Plate discipline 93% · Contact vs L 80% | 20,000 |
| 84 | [David Ortiz](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/awards-david-ortiz-0f575f79) (also DH) | 97 | BOS · Awards · Contact vs L 89% · Plate discipline 85% |  |
| 85 | [Al Kaline](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/awards-al-kaline-c0e66e73) (also RF) | 97 | DET · Awards · Plate vision 95% · Contact vs L 82% |  |
| 86 | [Mark Canha](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/kaiju-mark-canha-04f337d8) (also LF) | 97 | NYM · Kaiju · Plate vision 89% · Plate discipline 89% |  |
| 87 | [Prince Fielder](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/kaiju-prince-fielder-6dc1db86) | 99 | MIL · Kaiju · Plate discipline 93% · Contact vs R 80% | 47,200 |
| 88 | [Ernie Banks](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/milestone-ernie-banks-7658515a) (also SS) | 99 | CHC · Milestone · Plate vision 98% · Contact vs L 86% | 36,000 |
| 89 | [Don Mattingly](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-don-mattingly-b2fb92dd) | 99 | NYY · Finest · Plate vision 99% · Contact vs R 97% |  |
| 90 | [The Iron Horse](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/incognito-the-iron-horse-b6bffc02) | 97 | NYY · Incognito · Plate discipline 86% · Plate vision 86% |  |
| 91 | [Alex Bregman](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/captain-alex-bregman-0ad7b520) (also 3B) | 95 | HOU · Captain · Plate discipline 93% · Plate vision 92% |  |
| 92 | [Yasmani Grandal](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-yasmani-grandal-459a952d) (also C) | 99 | LAD · Finest · Plate discipline 96% · Contact vs R 92% |  |
| 93 | [Chase Utley](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/kaiju-chase-utley-e219fd52) (also 2B) | 99 | PHI · Kaiju · Plate vision 93% · Contact vs R 88% | 49,999 |
| 94 | [Joe Carter](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-joe-carter-b7b11557) (also RF) | 99 | TOR · Finest · Plate vision 98% · Contact vs L 90% |  |
| 95 | [Matt Olson](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/2023-all-star-matt-olson-62f08ee4) | 99 | ATL · 2023 All-Star · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs R 84% |  |
| 96 | [Nolan Arenado](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/awards-nolan-arenado-3e2c0b22) (also 3B) | 99 | COL · Awards · Plate vision 91% · Contact vs R 90% | 77,900 |
| 97 | [Adam Dunn](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/finest-adam-dunn-51401c2a) | 99 | WAS · Finest · Plate discipline 98% · Contact vs R 91% |  |
| 98 | [Wilmer Flores](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/2023-finest-wilmer-flores-f71cf8b3) | 99 | SF · 2023 Finest · Plate vision 95% · Contact vs L 84% |  |
| 99 | [Flying Dutchman](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/incognito-flying-dutchman-942713fd) (also SS) | 99 | PIT · Incognito · Plate vision 95% · Contact vs L 89% | 117,900 |
| 100 | [Anthony Santander](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/cards/2023-postseason-anthony-santander-94a4f345) (also RF) | 99 | BAL · 2023 Postseason · Contact vs R 97% · Contact vs L 84% |  |

## Other positions

- [catchers](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/best/eye/c)
- [second basemen](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/best/eye/2b)
- [third basemen](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/best/eye/3b)
- [shortstops](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/best/eye/ss)
- [left fielders](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/best/eye/lf)
- [center fielders](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/best/eye/cf)
- [right fielders](https://mlbtsdb.com/mlb23/best/eye/rf)
